This Earth, the only true home i ever had and will ever have, is not my world, i’m just a passerby in here … it is yours and it is strange.

  • 2 Posts
  • 13 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 13th, 2023

help-circle







  • Suppose we come to establish that the expansion rate accelerated from 68 to 73 km per second / Mpc (in the lapse of, say, 80% the ~14 B. years age of U.) if this is so, so be it. Why oppose it ?
    Or, if for the same period, we have two different rates … this is not acceleration. This is two methods yielding different results for what is supposed to be one sigle thing. So, one of the 2 methods doesn’t measure exactly the same thing as the other … whatever.

    Obviously, observation and measurement have to be the basis for any hypothesis and for any explanation proposals. So, we should not say : “since we have no explanation, there should not be acceleration of the expansion”. - - But rather we should say : “since there is acceleration of the expansion, we should build some theoretical models around this reality”.

    Anyway, you probably already know all of this.


  • i agree with you that here, the difference between 68 and 73 seems very small.

    For me, it’s even amazing that they get, for the CBM, any number even close to the same order of magnitude, given that it seems like a linear division of speed of light divided by light travel distance at the age of the universe, is the value for Hubble parameter (H)*_ at CBM.

    That seems in contradiction to the fact that, when adding relativistic velocities (and incrementally up to the speed of light !), linear addition is out of question and general relativity has to be used.

    This is just one of the apparent difficulties and obviously there are much more and harder challenges than this one.

    _*(… and is the age of the universe defined or measured by other means than simply :
    Δt = 1/H … ? That can’t be : since we have 2 parameters to evaluate, so, we need 2 independent experimental measurement variables. )